PPLD Update - As of Aug. 4, 2025
Published Mon., Aug. 4, 2025
Final Decision in the Baker , et al. vs. PPLD, et al. Lawsuit
On Mon., Aug. 4, the District Court of El Paso County granted Pikes Peak Library District’s (PPLD) Motion for Summary Judgment on the one remaining claim in Case No. 24CV32336, specifically PPLD’s alleged violation of the Open Meetings Law.
Earlier this year on May 7, the District Court judge granted PPLD’s Motion to Dismiss all claims except for the Open Meetings Law claim, requesting that the parties provide additional information before he would rule on it. In granting the Motion for Summary Judgment on this claim, the judge found that he did not have subject matter jurisdiction to review the Board decision not to renew the Rockrimmon Library lease, and that the undisputed evidence showed that PPLD had not violated the Open Meetings Law with respect to the October 2024 Board meeting where the decision was made. As such, the judge dismissed the claims with prejudice against all parties, including the individually-named defendants, who had been improperly named. The Court now considers the matter closed.
PPLD Updates - As of May 14, 2025
Published Wed., May 14, 2025
Update on PPLD's Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint in Baker, et al. v. PPLD, et al.
Below is an update concerning the lawsuit filed against Pikes Peak Library District and others regarding the non-renewal of the Rockrimmon Library lease:
On Wednesday, May 7th, the District Court of El Paso County granted Pikes Peak Library District’s (PPLD) Motion to Dismiss (Case No. 24CV32336) on all claims, except for one which remains pending. Due to the pending issue, PPLD will not be able to provide further comment.
Statement regarding COS Reads' New Library
PPLD previously raised concerns regarding potential confusion as to the library established by COS Reads. We’re pleased that steps are now being taken to address those concerns. As we said in our previous communication to PPLD cardholders, our intent is not to discourage new library initiatives, but PPLD has a responsibility to ensure that the public is not confused as to the source of those library services. We welcome the opportunity to move forward, and we remain committed to serving the Rockrimmon community.
PPLD Updates Regarding the Library in the Rockrimmon Area
Published Sun., April 27, 2025
Below is a letter that PPLD's attorney sent to the attorney for COS Reads on Thu., April 24.
View the PDF version of this letter
Page 2 of letter
Page 3 of letter
April 25, 2025: PPLD Updates Regarding the Library in the Rockrimmon Area
Published Fri., April 25, 2025
In the coming weeks, a new library will officially open in the Rockrimmon area. This library was created by COS Reads, the nonprofit organization spearheading the Save the Rockrimmon Library movement (the “COS Library”). These entities and the COS Library are completely independent of Pikes Peak Library District (“PPLD”).
PPLD is made up of 14 locations and Mobile Library Services (“MLS”) that have been serving the growing needs of El Paso County residents for more than 60 years. These locations operate in compliance with the Colorado Library Laws that lay out the rights and responsibilities of public libraries and their Board of Trustees, as well as govern library operations. PPLD’s adherence to these laws ensures that all patrons receive safe access to all the services, materials, resources, and equipment that the 14 official PPLD locations and MLS stops offer. Therefore, it is important that the District helps the public to understand that only its official locations offer these assurances, and that the COS Library is not affiliated with Pikes Peak Library District.
Some of the statements being made by these groups and the name that has been chosen for the COS Library are causing a bit of confusion for the public; books are being returned to the wrong locations; and the COS Library’s programs are bearing the same names as PPLD programs – Toddler Time and Paws to Read – giving the community the expectation of receiving the same quality service received at PPLD branches.
Please know that:
- For all PPLD programs that involve children, the staff presenting the programs are required to go through a nationally-accredited early children’s literacy training, along with a specific early literacy training. These trainings ensure that staff are knowledgeable on the developmental ages and stages of children, on how to use supplemental educational materials (such as, puppets or music) in the programs, and in “classroom” management techniques, etc.
- For all PPLD Paws to Read programs, the dogs are required to be therapy certified to ensure they can provide emotional support in diverse public settings. PPLD requires interviews for the handlers and assessments for the dogs. PPLD’s early literacy staff trains the handlers to work with young children, and the handlers must also complete the PPLD program expectations training. The handlers are provided with a Paws to Read Handbook, which they are required to read, acknowledge and agree to follow prior to hosting a program.
- All PPLD staff and volunteers must pass criminal background checks before they can be involved in any PPLD program or event.
Moreover, PPLD is bound by Colorado and federal laws that provide a legal framework for library operations and responsibilities. By way of example, PPLD safeguards the privacy of its patrons’ library records (C.R.S. § 24-90-119), has a statutory obligation to provide access to library resources that express all points of view (C.R.S. § 24-90-122), and uses Internet filters to restrict access to visual depictions of obscene materials, pornography, and/or any other material harmful to minors as required under the Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA).
Because the COS Library is privately operated, it is unclear whether it is required to comply with these laws – and it is even more uncertain whether patrons of the COS Library will understand that they do not have the same legal protections that they would have from PPLD. Therefore, PPLD wanted to inform the public that the COS Library is not affiliated with PPLD, that the COS Library is not an extension of PPLD, and that the COS Library is not bound by the same staff/volunteer training standards, background check requirements, or legal obligations as PPLD.
As these libraries are unaffiliated, PPLD patrons should know that any items checked out from one of its 14 locations or MLS stops must be returned to one of those locations or stops. They cannot be returned to the COS Library location. And items received from the COS Library cannot be returned to any PPLD locations; they will not be transferred to COS Library.
Know that PPLD is continuing to work for all its patrons throughout El Paso County, offering the quality and fulfilling services it has provided for decades. The Library District is thriving as the use of its amenities and participation in its programs, promotional campaigns, and donations continue to increase.
Thank you for your understanding and patience.
Pikes Peak Library District
Peter W. Choi
