After Earth

Image
After Earth
Title of Book
Author
David, Peter
Rating
1 star = Yuck!
Review

It's weird how a bit of hindsight brings a work into full focus. I never watched the movie After Earth (2013) because of its critical reception among audiences and critics alike. I figured maybe I would give the novel a try, not realizing it was not some work that the movie adapted, but instead a novelization of the movie itself. This was clearly a Will Smith passion project and never have I seen such blatant self-inserts in a work of fiction.

While the author of this novelization may be Peter David, Will Smith was behind much of this plot. Seeing the home life of the adult character in this book mirroring the home life that we know between Will and Jada is cringe-worthy. What's worse is that these characters (either the Will or the Jaden stand-ins) were so flat and boring as to be completely worthless. The plot that drives their adventure felt so juvenile that any group of six-year-olds could think it up playing on a playground. It's almost laughable that there were signs this was meant to be a bigger series.

Ultimately, After Earth is frustrating. It's a mediocre story with lackluster ideas. But, since a rich and famous person wanted to make it, Hollywood and Random House spent a lot of money to get it made. Thinking of all the fantastic (and nearly hidden) indie stories out there that will never get the amount of exposure that this bomb got makes me sad for the entertainment industry. Sure, sometimes there are breakthroughs, but these are rare as the rough edges of interesting works are sanded off to become marketable to the masses.

A nepotism story with no subtlety, I give After Earth 1.0 stars out of 5.

Reviewer's Name
Benjamin W.

Legion: Skin Deep

Image
Legion: Skin Deep
Title of Book
Author
Sanderson, Brandon
Rating
4 stars = Really Good
Review

Multiple personalities is one of those tropes that some writers use as a crutch to explain why their main character is so good at a litany of unique skills necessary to move the plot forward. And while the main character in Legion suffers from this superhuman trait, Brandon Sanderson still gives him enough weaknesses so that it's not entirely overpowered. Still, I can appreciate that this concept only took up three novellas (contained in this volume), since it can often overstay its welcome.

Each of the stories revolves around Stephen Leeds, a super-genius investigator who has portioned off his polymath of abilities to different personalities in his head. These personalities take up a physical space around him, even if nobody else can see them. Some of the "rules" around these invisible characters didn't seem to make much sense since they're allegedly all in Stephen's head, but I guess a character like this needs a Kryptonite to prevent him from solving all his problems so easily. I also had to suspend my disbelief with the mysteries Stephen was investigating, mostly rolling my eyes at the unbelievable nature of these concepts.

Overall, though, this trilogy of novellas is a solid read. It's basically a novel in three parts, as I've read full books longer than these three novellas put together. The unique personalities of the "personalities" were all quite entertaining, even if they overshadowed Stephen's somewhat milquetoast characteristics. The engineer in me wanted to know more about how this specific form of multiple personality disorder functioned, since it was a unique take on the disability. At any rate, if you're a fan of Sanderson's work, this is a quick read that proves he knows how to write in short form as well as his standard epic-length books.

An overdone trope that doesn't overstay its welcome, I give Legion 4.0 stars out of 5.

Reviewer's Name
Benjamin W.

The Call of Earth

Image
The Call of Earth
Title of Book
Author
Card, Orson Scott
Rating
2 stars = Meh
Review

After being so disappointed with The Memory of Earth , I'm surprised I gave the second volume in the Homecoming series a chance. I figured Orson Scott Card could have got things on track by this book, getting rid of all the unnecessary fluff and useless ramblings. Instead, The Call of Earth made it clear to me that I will not be continuing this series. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.

I think part of the problem with this series is how it's written. Having recently read an eye-opening book on identifying "Show versus Tell," it shocked me how much of this book was written with "Tell" language. Granted, a lot of science fiction and fantasy books have to do this to explain interesting magic or technologies. The Call of Earth, however, spent another whole book stuck in this pseudo-Roman society that most people can easily visualize. I'm still convinced he threw this series together to meet a deadline, because it has never felt that inspired.

What's most frustrating is knowing that it could be better. I was expecting this book to be about leaving their planet in search of Earth. Instead, they merely talked about it for 10 hours. None of the characters stood out to me, and whatever plot was there was so forgettable, I don't even care to look up what it was. I get that not every author is going to have all their books be amazing or thought-provoking. But two in a row doesn't give me much hope that the other three books in this series will be any better.

Another disappointing entry in Card's Homecoming series, I give The Call of Earth 2.0 stars out of 5.

Reviewer's Name
Benjamin W.

The Darkest Minds

Image
The Darkest Minds
Title of Book
Author
Bracken, Alexandra
Rating
4 stars = Really Good
Review

The Darkest Minds focuses solely on our main character, Ruby, a strong-willed, cautious girl who goes through major character growth and development throughout the book. Well, Ruby and the people she meets on her journey of staying alive when the world turns against teens due to a harmful mysterious virus that removed most of the child population. While Ruby did survive, she lost something almost as bad as her life, her parents. After being locked in a garage she was then sent to Thurmond--a brutal government rehabilitation camp of sorts that is far from its title by her own parents. On her journey, looking for stability she runs into Zu, a meek, sweet, and unsettled young girl around her age, presumably around 14. Chubs, the brains of the group and honestly incredibly mature, and finally Liam, a Southern seemingly fearless courageous leader. This memorable group of strong teenagers makes an impact that even they don't know they'll make in this book. I decided to read this book because some years ago when the movie came out I watched it with my brother and I loved it and wished that there was a sequel so I decided to read the entire series because I wanted some closure and I did not regret it.
What did you like about the book? I loved the well-written tight-knit teen relationships and slow-burn romance in this book. The personalities are pretty believable for the characters and I genuinely enjoyed the dialogue and internal thoughts that were portrayed.
There is a lot I like in this book, however of course there are some things I didn't like so much. For example, some events in the book feel a bit dragged out and some others are too short for the emotional weight of some situations that occur. Meaning they could use more explanation or information on the gravity of the event on people around them. If you're thinking "Hm, should I read this book? I would definitely say you should. I thought that this book was a nice read, especially on a day when It's raining and maybe it's later in the day. However, there are some situations that Ruby finds herself In that contain sensitive topics and I'd certainly recommend looking deeper into that on maybe a parental guidance website or another website of that sort if you have a sensitivity or trauma with that kind of thing that I will fail to mention in this review. Overall, The Darkest Minds Is a good read if you want a dystopian teen book with some romantic elements and combat elements. It reminds me of Divergent a bit however it is definitely its own thing and it has its sad moments but it is something you'd have to read on your own to really understand what it is like. When you start reading, you just can't put the book down at a certain point so it keeps your attention. Sometimes I wish I could read this book for the first time again, so make the most of it!

Reviewer's Name
Darray

Legend

Image
Legend
Title of Book
Author
Lu, Marie
Rating
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review

What was once known as the western half of the United States, is now known as a separate country called the republic, a plague-infested land at war with its eastern neighbors, the colonies. This book is an action filled adventure, going through the first person thoughts and actions of each character, let’s dive in.
The book starts out centered on a 15 year old boy named Day. Day is a national criminal after failing his trial (a test that all children have to take once their 10) and being a nuisance to the republic, downing fighter jets, and such. Each chapter switches between Day and June, already a military prodigy at the age of 15 years old. After Day steals plague suppressants from a hospital for his dying younger brother, he supposedly kills June's older brother, Metias, to escape. After June hears of this, she is desperate to avenge her brother's death, so she goes on an undercover mission in the slum sectors of Los Angeles, hoping to find information on Day. After coming across an illegal, underground fighting ring, (a skiz fight) she is pushed into the ring, where Tess (Day's acquaintance) saves her. Since Day and Tess' identities are unknown, June has no idea that Day is her savior, and travels around the city with them. After finding a clue that "the boy" is Day, Tess follows him and gives away his position to her superiors, leading to Day's capture. In the streets, the two became quite close, and Day told June that he believes the Republic uses the Republican people as lab rats for testing their plagues, before using them against the Colonies.
In conclusion, I think this book lives up to the review I gave it. I loved how every chapter ended with a cliffhanger, keeping the lights on late into the night. Definitely one of the best singular books I've ever read, but don't take my opinion, go read it for yourself!

Reviewer's Name
Zachary
Awards

The City of Ember

Image
The City of Ember
Title of Book
Author
DuPrau, Jeanne
Rating
4 stars = Really Good
Review

This book was super captivating as it was a search for truth and freedom. Throughout the book, we see the struggles of people in a dying city; the lights are running out, and the food is too. Through these problems, we see the attempts people make to survive, which lead to people stealing food and hiding it for themselves. Luckily two brave kids choose to find the truth and go on a journey to escape the city. When they finally find the light they realize their whole lives they were underground in the dark. A whole world was waiting for them at the top, but because no one was brave enough, they were stuck in their dying city. This book teaches us the importance of curiosity and the importance of hope; without these, people would be left to die in a dying city, never getting the chance to see the light.

Reviewer's Name
Matheo

Sea of Tranquility

Image
Sea of Tranquility
Title of Book
Author
Mandel, Emily St. John
Rating
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review

Science fiction often bogs itself down in the details of a potential future while forgetting the poetry that can come with the written word. It doesn't matter what scientific topic the book is handling if it's not entertaining to read. The best ones are a combination of speculative science, entertainment, and beautiful prose. I feel Sea of Tranquility meets these three criteria. The narrative is gripping, the framework thought-provoking, and the execution superb. I've never seen such a common sci-fi topic like this handled so well.

Time travel feels like it can be a crutch for a writer. It's a way to fill in details in a non-linear format that covers up any plot holes in a way that feels cheap. Jumping around in time can also make things confusing, as it isn't clear what era each section is set in. However, the way Emily St. John Mandel handles time travel in this book is probably one of the best I've seen. While following a linear timeline (somewhat akin to Cloud Atlas), the depth of time travel reveals itself with each jump into the future.

I think the reason I love how this book handles time travel is that each revisit of events adds layers of context that almost require an immediate second read-through of the entire book. Sure, the time travel explains away certain mysteries—but giving the reason behind those moments just elevates the story to higher levels. And throughout the whole thing, the descriptions, wording, and overall writing is just fantastic. Even if you don't like science fiction, this book stands out as a well-written piece of work that dives deeper into how humans can't ever know the full extent of a moment from a singular perspective.

The best time travel book I've ever read, I give Sea of Tranquility 5.0 stars out of 5.

Reviewer's Name
Benjamin W.

Annihilation

Image
Annihilation
Title of Book
Author
VanderMeer, Jeff
Rating
4 stars = Really Good
Review

Having already watched the 2018 movie adaptation of Annihilation , I knew going into this book that it would be quite the trip. My expectations were mostly set on what was going to happen in this book, but not on how the author would convey these events. I was pleasantly surprised with something that felt just as disorienting. Told in the first-person perspective, Annihilation messes with the concept of an unreliable narrator in a way that I haven’t ever seen before. The real question is whether I understand anything now that I’ve seen the movie and read the book.

There’s a melancholy present in Annihilation that almost borders on nihilism. The way the main character seems to float through this world, carrying her trauma and relational scars around in an eerily monotonous and emotionless manner, is both unsettling and oddly comforting. Was this her attempt at obtaining closure? Did she want to find somewhere she truly belonged? Whatever the reason, she is propelled forward by forces outside her control, and she doesn’t resist any of the alien influence.

The prose in Annihilation is truly the star of the show here. Other writers might try to take a more scientific approach when dealing with aliens, but VanderMeer leans into the disorienting nature of Area X. I’ve been drunk a few times, but never high enough to hallucinate like this. Several times I had to stop and re-read a page to understand what was happening. Once I turned my mind off and let the words flow through me, I had a much more enjoyable time in this book. I don’t know if I’ll get through the rest of the trilogy, but this one was worth the read.

A trippy hallucination of a novel, I give Annihilation 4.0 stars out of 5.

Reviewer's Name
Benjamin W.
Awards

The Infinity Particle

Image
The Infinity Particle
Title of Book
Author
Xu, Wendy
Rating
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review

The Infinity Particle is about a futuristic world where humans have colonized Mars and have advanced technology. Clementine is a young girl who has just moved to Mars to get a start at a new life. She is working with her hero, as she is one of the most talented people to work in the field of robotics. On her first day, her and her personal robot SENA meet Kye, a personal humanoid robot built by Clem’s hero. Soon, Clem finds out her hero is not who she believed her to be, and Kye is malfunctioning. Clem and Kye have to work together to solve this mystery, and in doing so, they unearth both Clem and Kye’s troubled pasts, and they grow closer together. It’s a great book!

Reviewer's Name
Tegan

Messenger

Image
Cover of Messenger by Lois Lowry
Title of Book
Author
Lois Lowry
Rating
4 stars = Really Good
Review

Continuing the passionate Giver series, Lois Lowry’s masterpiece “Messenger” is a book for the ages. As Matty, the lovable child from Kira’s town, has grown and changed in his new home, Village, his home has begun to change with him. Village is a place of acceptance and supports all that come to live there— or was, until recently. A darkness is creeping toward the small village through the surrounding forest, and the people have begun to turn on their old, kind ways. As Village threatens to close, Matty must do what no other can — to find Kira and bring her back safely.
Filled with an electric mix of mystery, suspense, and emotion, Messenger is able to explore complex emotions and develop character’s personalities while still incorporating the eternal struggle of good vs evil. Shocking plot twists and vivid imagery add to this book’s intense depth and perspective. It is definitely worth the read if only just for the ending.

Reviewer's Name
Dominic
Subscribe to Science Fiction