An Ember in the Ashes book jacket
Tahir, Sabaa
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The world building in this book was amazing and made the story feel so immersive. I loved the dual perspectives because they helped show both sides of the conflict and made the characters more complex. The pacing was fast, and there were so many emotional and suspenseful moments throughout the novel. Some scenes were heartbreaking, but that made the story even more memorable. I would highly recommend this book to those who enjoy fantasy and dystopian romance.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
Sunrise on the Reaping book jacket
Collins, Suzanne
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This book is not for the weak hearted. It is the prequel to The Hunger Games, and this tale follows Haymitch, a former victor and Katniss's mentor, as he tries to survive a deadly Quarter Quell in a beautifully cruel arena. With double the tributes, chances for Haymitch are small, but he decides to either break the arena or die trying, leaving his lover back in District 12. Possibly the saddest of the Hunger Games series, but a definite must read. After all, someone has to stop that sunrise from rising on the reaping. You'll catch my reference if you read the book.

Reviewer's Name: Lucy
The Hunger Games book jacket
Collins, Suzanne
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I believe this book is a must read, if you can stomach it. It’s a classic dystopian novel about a dictatorship government and an annual event: The Hunger Games. Kids are reaped from the outlying districts and forced to compete to the death in exchange for extra food that year. This whole series follows a young victor and her attempt to overthrow the Capitol, and change the way the games are played forever. Happy Hunger Games, and may the odds be ever in your favor.
Reviewer Grade 8

Reviewer's Name: Lucy
The Memory Police book jacket
Ogawa, Yoko
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Memory Police by Yoko Ogawa as a chilling yet heartwarming dystopia that dives into the intricacies of memory and identity. It follows the journey of the protagonist, an unnamed female novelist, as she navigates her changing world. The story is set on a remote island where objects and memories systematically disappear, leaving holes in the hearts and minds of the people. It leads the reader to question, alongside the protagonist, what role our pasts and our memories play in shaping our identities, and it masterfully taps into the fear of losing oneself. I have only rated this book three stars because although it was an enjoyable read, it got dull at times and I found some of the subplots to be more distracting than impactful.

Reviewer's Name: Addison
Release Me
Mafi, Tahereh
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

In the second book of the “New Republic" series, Mafi continuously raises the stakes for Rosabelle and James. Both Rosabelle and James have been lied to, and now they must make the final decision to trust each other or watch their new world fall apart.

This was so amazing!! If I’ve said it once I’ve said it a thousand times: Tahereh Madi’s writing is unreal. There were times I was reading this novel and just marveling about how the author sat behind a computer screen and wrote them into existence. They feel so real! Of course, the plot is absolutely amazing too. Mafi takes everything suspenseful and amazing from Shatter Me and Watch Me and triples it in Release Me. I could not put this novel down and yet, I’m so disappointed I finished it. September cannot come fast enough for book 3! If you’re a Shatter Me fan and you haven’t read this new series yet, get on it. I promise it is absolutely worth it.

Reviewer's Name: Cara
The Crown Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Crown by Kiera Cass is the fifth and final book in The Selection series. It is a sequel to book four and cannot be read as a standalone.
The book continues immediately from the previous one where Eadlyn’s mother has suffered from a heart attack and her father announces her as Regent of Illea while he takes care of her mother. She resumes her Selection process with the remaining suitors, while handling political unrest, social tensions, and pressure over potential political marriages.
In the end, she goes against the traditional Selection rules, following her heart and concluding the series in a fulfilling resolution.
In my opinion, this book was entertaining with much more drama than the books that came before it. Eadlyn’s growth arc was satisfying, considering how frustrating her character started out as.
I would recommend this book to those who like romantic dramas, royalty stories, and political intrigue in YA fiction.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Heir Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
2 stars = Meh
Review:

The Heir by Kiera Cass is the fourth book in The Selection series and can be read without having prior read the first three books in the series.
The story takes place about twenty years after the third book and is centered on Maxon and America’s first-born daughter, who was born a few minutes before her twin brother, making her the first female heir to the throne in Illea’s history.
The caste system has been abolished, but discrimination and tension in the kingdom continue to persist. As a “distraction” for the people, Princess Eadlyn is convinced to have a Selection to find a husband.
In the beginning, she presents herself as rude and unapproachable but as she gets to know the men, her view of love changes.
In my opinion, this book was engaging but a little unoriginal, building on the concept of the first three books. Eadlyn can be spoiled and self-centered, which may frustrate some readers, though her growth throughout the story adds depth.
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy romantic dramas, princess stories, and dystopian settings.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The One Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The One by Kiera Cass is the third book in The Selection series and cannot be read as a standalone.
In the third book of the series, the Selection continues on with America as part of the three girls left, competing for Prince Maxon’s heart. America must finally confront her feelings for Maxon and Aspen, as tensions in the kingdom rise and rebels threaten the royal family. She makes her decision, relationships are clarified, and the series is mostly resolved.
In my opinion, this book was a satisfying conclusion to America’s story. Although the love triangle and plot were mostly predictable, the author’s writing was engaging.
I would recommend this book to people who like romantic dramas, love triangles, and dystopian royalty stories.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Elite Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Elite by Kiera Cass is the second book in The Selection series and cannot be read as a standalone.
In the second installment of the series, the Selection contest carries on with six remaining finalists as America grapples with her growing feelings for Prince Maxon and her lingering feelings for Aspen, who now works as a guard at the palace. She also struggles with jealousy, competition, and the manipulation of the other five finalists.
In my opinion, this book was less entertaining than the first one and by this point, the plot started to drag a little. The love triangle drama remained partially forced and America was still a frustrating lead character.
I would recommend this book to people who liked royalty romances, love triangles, and light drama filled YA novels.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Selection Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Selection by Kiera Cass is a romance novel, set in a dystopian future where there is a strict caste system (with one being the royals and eight being the criminals) that decides what job you have in the kingdom of Illea.
The story is centered on America Singer, a girl from caste five who has a future in music, when she is chosen for The Selection. The Selection is a televised contest where 35 girls vie for the hand of Prince Maxon, heir to the throne.
America, in the beginning, has no interest in the prince and harbors feelings for her secret boyfriend Aspen, from caste six. But as she gets to know Maxon, they develop a complicated romantic connection.
In my opinion, the book was entertaining, and Kiera Cass’s writing has a distinct voice. However, America was a frustrating main character. The story was rather predictable and the love triangle drama seemed almost forced at points.
I would recommend this book to people who like romance novels, dystopian settings, and lighthearted love triangle drama.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Hunger Games book jacket
Collins, Suzanne
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

"The Hunger Games" by Suzanne Collins is about a Capitol that controls 12 districts, and every year, the districts have to get one female and one male that are drawn at random to participate in the Hunger Games. The book shows what happened at the 74th games, and shows the experience that the main character, Katniss Everdeen, faces. This book really kept me engaged, and any time a chapter ended, I could not wait to see what would happen next. I felt inspired and looked up to the main character, as she was very clever and strong willed, as she was independent and had so much determination. I usually have trouble reading books in a series, but I was able to easily move on to the next book and finish the series in no time. "The Hunger Games" is one of my favorite books that I read this year, and I recommend this to everyone.

Reviewer's Name: Saadhana
Sky's End book jacket
Gregson, Marc J
1 star = Yuck!
Review:

Conrad of Urwin lives in a brutal Meritocracy, where people are divided into Highs, Middles, and Lows based not only on their family's legacy, but also their strength in combat. As Conrad and his mother struggle as Lows, he soon has no choice but to turn to the person he loathes most in this world - his uncle. And while his uncle promises to reunite Conrad with his sister, the only way to save her is to enter the Selection for the Twelve Trades and prove that he is powerful enough to earn his place in the Urwin family. However, as he embarks on this dangerous journey, Conrad must decide how far he will go in order to rise...

As much as I wanted to like "Sky's End," I honestly couldn't find any redeeming qualities within the story. From the very beginning, the writing style and pacing were off, making the book extremely difficult to read, as the time skips completely interrupted the flow and action. Not only did this severely affect the story itself, but it also made significant events (like character deaths) seem to carry no weight. Additionally, there was no clear organization or climax to the story, making the entire book seem stagnant, confusing, and rushed. None of the characters (including Conrad) were likable or dynamic, and the sexist undertones throughout the book and blatant objectification of female characters did not sit right with me as a reader.

Reviewer's Name: Addelyn
Uglies
Westerfield, Scott
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This is a very thought-provoking book that sends important messages about confidence and beauty standards. In this book, Tally Youngblood meets a new trouble-making (like her) friend named Shay after her best friend leaves to go to New Pretty Town after his plastic surgery. When she leaves the city to join the Smoke, a group of Uglies living out in the wilderness, she is told to find them, or she will never get her surgery. However, the people and lifestyle she encounters there make her start rethinking everything. I think how shallow and selfish she is portrayed is very interesting because most protagonists aren’t like that and it really shows the effect her society has had on her. She has been trained to be how she is, and I think the story of her overcoming that was way more interesting than it would have been had it been from the perspective of someone who had already overcome that like Shay. I think that it has good themes, induces complex discussions, and is overall just a very interesting book.

Reviewer's Name: Danielle
Imagine Me book jacket
Mafi, Tahereh
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

Imagine Me provides a clear, satisfying ending for the second arc of Shatter Me books. However, I expected Imagine Me to be action packed and to make me not want to put the book down. Instead, everything felt slow and calculated, almost how you would expect the second book in a trilogy to go. Some scenes and plot arcs felt underdeveloped, or completely unnecessary.

While the plot was slow, and it was sometimes a struggle to pick up the book, Tahereh Mafi was still able to do what she does best: develop her characters. She established new relationships that built off previous experiences, developed all of her characters from the supreme leaders to the main characters we've been rooting for since day 1. I felt the characters are what made the book enjoyable, not the plot.

Despite Imagine Me's underdeveloped plot, I would still recommend it if you want to finish the series on a good note, with most if not all plot points resolved in a satisfying way. It just didn't have the same emotional punch in my opinion as the previous Shatter Me books, which is why I rated it 3 stars.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
Animal Farm
Orwell, George
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

It was just a regular farm until the animals revolted. The animals had had enough cruel treatment and decided that they were going to run the farm. The pigs took charge reading the farm. One pig took control with his nine ferocious dogs and killed all those who opposed to him. The animals worked as slaves from them on out, never complaining because if they did, they knew they would meet their rent. As the pig says in the book, "All animals are equal, but some are more equal than others."

Reviewer's Name: Kyla
Sunrise on the Reaping
Collins, Suzanne
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

On the day of the fifteenth annual Hunger Games, the nation of Panem is in turmoil. In light of the second Quarter Quell, Haymitch Abernathy has been set up for failure, with double the tributes in the most brutal bloodbath of the Hunger Games. But despite the impossibility of his odds, Haymitch only has one goal: to cause the downfall of the Capital.

Oh my gosh, Haymitch’s story is so unbelievably heartbreaking, but definitely a story worth being told. Suzanne Collins continues to blow my mind with all the parallels between the original Hunger Games series and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. Finally knowing Haymitch’s side of the story gives his role in The Hunger Games a whole new meaning and depth that breaks my heart even further. The only complaint I would have would be how long the first half of the book took. I know there needs to be some lead up that happens before the games, but it just felt a little too long compared to the second half. The epilogue though was one of the most compelling I think I’ve ever read, as it helps finalize his character within the entire Hunger Games franchise. I cannot wait for the movie!

Reviewer's Name: Cara
Defy Me book jacket
Mafi, Tehereh
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Defy Me is the fifth book in the Shatter Me series. Defy Me is a great follow up read after the cliffhanger Restore Me ends on. Answers and action are well paced throughout the book, with no part feeling too slow or too fast. Most questions asked in Restore Me, and some that you might not realize you had, are answered through flashbacks and knowledge from older characters.

The action is fast paced and serves to help develop the characters and their relationships. Every character has a clear defined goal, and while they have different goals Tahereh Mafi is still able to make them work together without ideals clashing. I finished this book in 2 days right after finishing Restore Me. I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys the Shatter Me series. Not only are new continents introduced, but newer characters are developed as well as the original characters that were present in the first book. Tahereh Mafi does a wonderful job of not spending too much time developing her main characters, and focusing on the new ones, while also not leaving the original characters how they were at the end of Ignite Me and further developing them as well.

This was one of my favorite books in the entire series, and I would recommend any fan of Shatter Me continues the series with this read.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
Restore Me book jacket
Mafi, Tehereh
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Restore Me is a continuation of the Shatter Me series. It has the same characters, same setting, but the enemy is more than just Anderson, it is now the entire Reestablishment. Juliette is now the commander of Sector 45, and is working to destroy the Reestablishment from within. However, she still has much to learn about her friends, her enemies, and herself.

Restore Me is not as action packed as the previous Ignite Me because it serves as a bridge to set up a new story arc that introduces new problems, new revelations, and new characters. I had previously heard the second arc of the Shatter Me series was not worth reading because it was too confusing and it seemed like the author was only writing this plot for money. I disagree. Tahereh Mafi expands her world from Sector 45 and shows the characters grappling with the new information they are learning, especially Juliette.

This book includes nonstop reveals about popular characters, like Juliette, Warner and Kenji, that made it almost impossible to put down. Every chapter I learned something new that didn't feel forced, but rather enlightening. I didn't rate this book 5 stars, because at times the action is slow while Juliette is learning more about the world around her. I think it is well worth your time to read Restore Me if you loved the first three Shatter Me novels and want to continue your adventure with the characters and world.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
The Maze Runner
Dashner, James
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

This is an exciting read, if not very realistic. It follows a trapped society surrounded on all sides by a moving maze. At night, horrific creatures lurk within the maze walls, but the inhabitants are protected by huge walls. That is, until Thomas shows up. At first, nothing is out of the ordinary, until a girl shows up the very next day. Soon, things begin to change and escaping the maze becomes even more necessary. It is a very fast paced book and it's good for all ages. I would try this book, but it's not a must read.

Reviewer's Name: Lucy
Divergent book jacket
Roth, Veronica
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

When I first read this book, I was really intrigued by the faction system and the idea of sorting people by personality. The beginning felt strong and made me want to keep reading, especially as the main character Tris started her training. However, as the story went on, some of the characters felt underdeveloped, and the romance didn’t fully work for me. A lot of the conflict seemed to rely on predictable choices rather than surprising ones. I still think it’s entertaining and easy to read, but it didn’t leave a lasting emotional impact on me.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
Red Queen book jacket
Aveyard, Victoria
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

This book had an interesting premise, and I liked the idea of a world divided by blood color. At first, I was really invested in the protagonist Mare’s journey and her shock at discovering her powers. However, as the plot continued, it started to feel like a mix of other dystopian stories I’ve already read. Some twists were predictable, and the characters didn’t feel as complex as I wanted them to be. I enjoyed parts of it, but it didn’t stand out enough for me to rate it higher.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
The Hunger Games Book Jacket
Collins, Suzanne
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

This book completely pulled me in from the very first chapter, and I remember feeling tense the entire time I was reading it. Being inside Katniss’s head made everything feel urgent and real, especially the fear and pressure she feels just trying to survive. What I loved most was how the book isn’t just about the Games themselves, but about the themes of power, sacrifice, and how unfair systems hurt people who never asked to be part of them. The relationships, especially between Katniss and Peeta, felt complicated and realistic rather than overly romantic. By the end, I felt emotionally drained in the best way, and it made me think long after I closed the book!!

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
Uglies book jacket
Westerfeld, Scott
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

Uglies by Scott Westerfeld is about Tally Youngblood who lives in a futuristic dystopian society where everyone is considered an “Ugly” until they get cosmetic surgery and become a “Pretty.” Tally chooses to rebel against becoming a “Pretty” when her friends Shay and David show her that being a “Pretty” isn’t all that it is made out to be.
In my opinion, this book was nice. While the story was interesting, some parts were predictable.
I would recommend this book to anyone who likes dystopian stories, adventure, and coming-of-age novels.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
Nobody book cover
Barnes, Jennifer Lynn
2 stars = Meh
Review:

I typically love anything JLB puts out but this felt flat. The prospect was intriguing but the book dragged and was very dry. The romance felt rushed and had no chemistry. I honestly was so bored to death and had cringed so much I just did not finish the book. I would not recommend this book, but I would recommend the author!

Reviewer's Name: Abby
The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes book cover
Collins, Suzanne
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

The Hunger Games is my favorite series of all time and a story about Snow? Yes please! The whole book I found myself rooting for Snow even though I knew the evil he perpetrated and that speaks volumes to Collins writing. This extra to the series was something that was not a money grab but a book that answered many questions that I had. The continued world building and easter eggs added so much to the series and I loved it so much! This book is the perfect villian original story, showing how a character you root for can turn out absolutely evil. If I could give this a million stars I would.

Reviewer's Name: Abby
Wool book cover
Howey, Hugh
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Wool is single-handedly the best politically dystopian book I have ever read, as well as #2 best book I have ever read. Howey masterfully extricates critical thought from the reader, not even mentioning some really deep aspects of what a political situation might fully manifest, causing the reader to add their own reasons they generated implied from this epic presentation of situations to more obvious reasons explicitly stated as an ever-present apex of human analysis in Wool. Consider satire -- presented simply and relatively easy to understand. Even slightly comical. But when analyzed and context is applied, it becomes a powerful tool, causing the reader to read in reverence at the wisdom of the author. Although not satire, Wool certainly gave me reverence toward Hugh Howey. If I were to see him walking down the street, a great effort would be made on my part to engage in conversation, second only to Ted Dekker. This critical thought and other implied assumptions left me feeling respected as a reader -- my intelligence is welcome for more than guessing the future plot: understanding the story. I believe the more intelligent the person, the more they will enjoy Wool.

Wool is book one of the Silo series. Book two is technically a prequel (to the perspective of the world, not Howey) but definitely read Wool before Shift. Incredibly powerful as a stand-alone, the Silo series collectively can move mountains. After finishing Dust, I began tearing up. I never tear up. For such a logical book where every decision is made rationally (until Juliet), Howey elicited an emotional response from me. The theme stressed across the Silo series is: "For so long we have chosen to do what is logical and rational. What statistically makes sense. But I fear the solution to this problem lies in doing what is right. Following the heart and not the brain." (NOT a quote from the Silo series).

As an aspiring engineer with straight As, this hit me hard. As someone who seeks efficiency and celebrates structure this broke me. In that moment when I realized what Howey was trying to drive through my logically intelligent but emotionally stubborn mind, I had to STOP reading. I read the paragraph three times. Respecting Howey for his political depth and logical nuance, I was offended for but one second when this dawned of me. And then I realized he was right.

Go make a realization.

Reviewer's Name: Lincoln
Legend book cover
Marie Lu
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

As book one in the six-book series, it will also read well as a standalone. I like how the world is explained throughout the book - rather than dumping me with all worldbuilding in the beginning, or especially all at once. By the end of the book, new things are still being learned about Tess (the protagonist's sidekick). But is Day really the protagonist, or is it June? Although the story is admittedly more focused on Day, June's impact on Day's life is by far the more entertaining part of the book. Every chapter alternates perspectives, like a good Red Pyramid or The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel -- appropriate, political (if you will), and disappointing when really invested in what's about to happen next.

The Republic is one of two factions the U.S. splits into after collapse -- home to elite military families like the one June comes from, but also home to beggars, drunks, homeless, and the poor like Day. June is at some point convinced that Day murdered her brother (a spoiler from page 1) and vows to hunt him down both for revenge and to prove herself to the Republic. But as she gets close with Day, she uncovers truths about the Republic causing her to question her involvement.

Happy Ending

Reviewer's Name: Lincoln
The Scorch Trials Book Jacket
Dashner, James
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This book is an amazing addition to the Maze Runner series. As the last book ended we got insight into WICKED that the Gladers don’t know. This creates a urge to help them, even though you can’t, and a mix of emotions. When they figure out the truth they realize what they must to do survive. This creates even more emotions in the reader and the characters. They immediately face challenges even in what seems like the easiest part of the trial. As they cross the Scorch, make new friends, and maybe lose some of the ones you thought were forever. This book is thrilling, exciting, and very emotional as it takes you through what might be the Gladers hardest trial.

Reviewer's Name: Anikka, Grade 8
The Maze Runner Book Jacket
Dashner, James
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I really liked this book. I read it after watching the movie and it was similar, but still had some differences. I really liked the different things that happened when the end started coming. With the progress of Thomas emotionally and physically it shows the progress of not only the other Gladers, but also the book and Glade itself. Even though I watched the movie before reading the book, I still was able to be surprised and enter the world of the maze. Even though there is a lot of things going on it still is a thrilling rollercoaster of emotions. As Thomas grows more knowledgeable of the maze I did to. It brought the truth to my eyes as Thomas realized it for himself.

Reviewer's Name: Anikka, Grade 8
The Giver Book Jacket
Lowry, Lois
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

First off, if you're looking for a comedy, this isn't it. Move along. This novel is the first in a four-book dystopian series. Lowry has a new take on dystopia as she describes what appears to be the perfect community--no hunger, homelessness, or unemployment. It is a well oiled machine. Jobs are assigned, as are spouses and children, who come from predetermined Birthmothers, which is one job of many. However, Jonas isn't assigned to a job. He is selected to be the new Receiver. Within the job, he learns exactly what's wrong with his community and discovers what wondrous things his community has omitted. I know it sounds boring but I have read it so many times; the whole series, actually. I think it is a great book for tweens and above. The whole series is great and I really liked them.

Reviewer's Name: Lucy, Grade 8