The Fault in Our Stars
Green, John
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

The Fault in Our Stars by John Green is a brilliant and heart-warming book truly worth reading. The novel follows 17-year-old Hazel Grace Lancaster dealing with stage 4 cancer as she faces teenage life, family, her inevitable decline, and her heart. During support group she meets Augustus Waters an intelligent and funny guy who desires to be remembered. They form a close-knit friendship and bond over the book “An Imperial Affliction” until soon their friendship turns into their star-crossed love. They adventure with Issac —another guy from support group—, see the art piece “Funky Bones”, and eventually travel to Amsterdam to see the author of “An Imperial Affliction”. But awaiting their return to the U.S. is the devastating turn around that no one expects.

This book will make you laugh, cry, and will leave you wanting to reread it. John Green’s writing style is beautiful and the love story he writes is one of the greatest ever told. The characters are written incredibly and the attachment I personally felt with this book is one I have never felt before. The novel is captivating and I recommend it to anyone because everyone can find some piece relatable. You will not regret reading this book!

Reviewer's Name: Claire
How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates book jacket
Thompson, Shailee
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

“How to Kill a Guy in Ten Dates” mixes rom-coms and horror into one great slasher novel. When Jamie decides to attend a speed-dating event with her best friend Laurie, the last thing she expects is to be forced into a real life slasher film. As tensions run high, she realizes she may not only be in a makeshift slasher movie, but it seems like the killer is attempting to create a romantic comedy atmosphere as well. With her wits and fellow daters, Jamie must use everything she’s learned from her years of watching and studying horror films to survive the night and hopefully find her happily ever after.

I thought this concept was so cool. While I found the plot twist to be sort of predictable, as a slasher enjoyer myself, I found the novel to be very entertaining. I was on the edge of my seat the whole time waiting to see who would survive and who would succumb to horror tropes. While I thought it was interesting, I didn’t love the rom-com aspect of the novel. I thought that part was boring and not very well developed. But, I absolutely love how the author tied it in with the ending!

Reviewer's Name: Cara
The Crown Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Crown by Kiera Cass is the fifth and final book in The Selection series. It is a sequel to book four and cannot be read as a standalone.
The book continues immediately from the previous one where Eadlyn’s mother has suffered from a heart attack and her father announces her as Regent of Illea while he takes care of her mother. She resumes her Selection process with the remaining suitors, while handling political unrest, social tensions, and pressure over potential political marriages.
In the end, she goes against the traditional Selection rules, following her heart and concluding the series in a fulfilling resolution.
In my opinion, this book was entertaining with much more drama than the books that came before it. Eadlyn’s growth arc was satisfying, considering how frustrating her character started out as.
I would recommend this book to those who like romantic dramas, royalty stories, and political intrigue in YA fiction.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Heir Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
2 stars = Meh
Review:

The Heir by Kiera Cass is the fourth book in The Selection series and can be read without having prior read the first three books in the series.
The story takes place about twenty years after the third book and is centered on Maxon and America’s first-born daughter, who was born a few minutes before her twin brother, making her the first female heir to the throne in Illea’s history.
The caste system has been abolished, but discrimination and tension in the kingdom continue to persist. As a “distraction” for the people, Princess Eadlyn is convinced to have a Selection to find a husband.
In the beginning, she presents herself as rude and unapproachable but as she gets to know the men, her view of love changes.
In my opinion, this book was engaging but a little unoriginal, building on the concept of the first three books. Eadlyn can be spoiled and self-centered, which may frustrate some readers, though her growth throughout the story adds depth.
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy romantic dramas, princess stories, and dystopian settings.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The One Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The One by Kiera Cass is the third book in The Selection series and cannot be read as a standalone.
In the third book of the series, the Selection continues on with America as part of the three girls left, competing for Prince Maxon’s heart. America must finally confront her feelings for Maxon and Aspen, as tensions in the kingdom rise and rebels threaten the royal family. She makes her decision, relationships are clarified, and the series is mostly resolved.
In my opinion, this book was a satisfying conclusion to America’s story. Although the love triangle and plot were mostly predictable, the author’s writing was engaging.
I would recommend this book to people who like romantic dramas, love triangles, and dystopian royalty stories.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Elite Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Elite by Kiera Cass is the second book in The Selection series and cannot be read as a standalone.
In the second installment of the series, the Selection contest carries on with six remaining finalists as America grapples with her growing feelings for Prince Maxon and her lingering feelings for Aspen, who now works as a guard at the palace. She also struggles with jealousy, competition, and the manipulation of the other five finalists.
In my opinion, this book was less entertaining than the first one and by this point, the plot started to drag a little. The love triangle drama remained partially forced and America was still a frustrating lead character.
I would recommend this book to people who liked royalty romances, love triangles, and light drama filled YA novels.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Selection Book Jacket
Cass, Kiera
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Selection by Kiera Cass is a romance novel, set in a dystopian future where there is a strict caste system (with one being the royals and eight being the criminals) that decides what job you have in the kingdom of Illea.
The story is centered on America Singer, a girl from caste five who has a future in music, when she is chosen for The Selection. The Selection is a televised contest where 35 girls vie for the hand of Prince Maxon, heir to the throne.
America, in the beginning, has no interest in the prince and harbors feelings for her secret boyfriend Aspen, from caste six. But as she gets to know Maxon, they develop a complicated romantic connection.
In my opinion, the book was entertaining, and Kiera Cass’s writing has a distinct voice. However, America was a frustrating main character. The story was rather predictable and the love triangle drama seemed almost forced at points.
I would recommend this book to people who like romance novels, dystopian settings, and lighthearted love triangle drama.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
Atmosphere book jacket
Reid, Taylor Jenkins
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Joan Goodwin has always dreamed of the stars. In 1980s Houston, NASA is finally willing to begin integrating women astronauts into the program. With her group of fellow astronaut candidates, Joan navigates a world of love, family, and friends in a word slowly beginning to accept diversity.

I was very surprised at how much I enjoyed this novel. Having enjoyed other Reid books, I knew I would have some level of enthusiasm, but I liked it much more than I thought I would. For starters, I have always been intrigued by space and space travel, so I especially enjoyed the whimsical personality Joan obtained throughout the story. I also absolutely adored the relationship between Joan and her niece, Frances. Frances was probably my favorite character by far, as she was so lively and felt so real even as a fictional child. I didn’t care for the love story much, which would be my only complaint, but I was fascinated at how well Reid weaved the intricacies of romance and occupations in the time period of the 1980s.

Reviewer's Name: Cara
The Final Gambit book jacket
Barnes, Jennifer Lynn
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Final Gambit by Jennifer Lynn Barnes is the third book in The Inheritance Games series and cannot be read as a standalone.
The final installment follows the final weeks leading up to Avery Grambs’s eighteenth birthday when she will officially inherit Tobias Hawthorne’s fortune. This book introduces a visitor from outside the Hawthorne family, adding a new mystery and extra layers of conflict.
In my opinion, while I enjoy the concept of the universe and the puzzles, this book felt somewhat unnecessary. I understand that a satisfying conclusion was required, but by this point, the mystery felt forced and the love triangle drama felt like filler. Additionally, Avery’s character still felt overly adaptable and lacked distinctive growth, and the series’ signature riddles and puzzles, while clever, no longer felt as engaging or surprising. The resolution wrapped up loose ends but did so in a way that sometimes felt rushed or convenient.
I would recommend this book to those who have already read the first two books in the series and enjoy puzzle-driven mysteries, family intrigue, and romantic tension.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Hawthorne Legacy book jacket
Barnes, Jennifer Lynn
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The Hawthorne Legacy by Jennifer Lynn Barnes is the second book in The Inheritance Games series and it can’t be read as a standalone.
The book is about solving the mystery of how Avery Grambs is connected to Tobias Hawthorne and why she inherited his fortune. The story introduces more riddles, puzzles, and twists, while simultaneously intensifying the love triangle conflicts between Grayson Hawthorne and Jameson Hawthorne.
In my opinion, the book was engaging and kept me turning pages quickly, with clever puzzles and moments of suspense that made it fun to read. But, while the sequel expands the mystery, it lacks the tight-pacing or the satisfying puzzle-solving of the first book, often leading to repetition of structure. The novel leans heavily into the love triangle and ongoing riddles, but the central reveal doesn’t feel as impactful as the buildup suggests. Like many middle books in a trilogy, it spends more time setting up future twists than delivering a fully satisfying story on its own.
I would recommend this book to those who have already read the first book in the series and enjoy mysteries, clever puzzles, and romantic tension.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The Inheritance Games book jacket
Barnes, Jennifer Lynn
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The Inheritance Games by Jennifer Lynn Barnes follows Avery Grambs, a teenage girl living in her car, when she—out of the blue—becomes the youngest billionaire when she inherits billionaire Tobias Hawthorne’s money.
The catch? She has to live in the Hawthorne Mansion alongside the family Tobias Hawthorne just disinherited while solving riddles and puzzles.
In my opinion, this book was enjoyable. The short chapters led to a fast-paced book with a love-triangle subplot. Personally, I found most of the characters likable except for Jameson Hawthorne—one of Tobias’s four grandsons—and Avery, herself. Jameson had a tendency to speak in riddles and nonsense that made no sense, and his “rebellious” behavior was, at points, irritating. While Avery Kylie Grambs is positioned as a relatable and grounded protagonist, her personality often feels too adaptable and indistinct, making it difficult to form a strong emotional connection with her.
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy fast-paced mysteries, riddles and brain teasers, and love triangles.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
The School for Good and Evil book jacket
Chainani, Soman
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The School for Good and Evil by Soman Chainani follows the two opposite best friends Sophie and Agatha, who are unexpectedly taken from their village home to the fabled School for Good and Evil where children are trained to become fairy-tale heroes and villains.
Sophie, who dreams of being a princess with her pink dresses and countless good deeds, is placed in the School for Evil, while Agatha, who sees herself as an outcast, is sent to the School for Good.
As they struggle to fit into their unexpected roles, the girls begin to question what truly makes someone “good” or “evil,” and their friendship is tested as they try to find a way back home.
In my opinion, this book was great. The writing style was entertaining and descriptive, and I thought it was a unique twist on common fairytale tropes. Sophie and Agatha were both likable characters for entirely different reasons—Sophie is more than what she seems while Agatha cannot see past her appearance.
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy twisted fairy tales, magical school settings, and character-driven stories.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
Carrie Soto is Back Book Jacket
Reid, Taylor Jenkins
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Carrie Soto had it all. Since training with her father since the age of two, she has become the only women’s tennis player to win 20 grand slams. Her career was shaped by grueling and tireless matches, and now one woman threatens to take it all. The year is 1994 and Nicki Chan has officially matched Carrie’s record of 20 slams. Not willing to let her greatest player title be taken, Carrie makes the shocking decision to come out of retirement at age 37 in order to defend her record.

Wow! This book was really exciting! I originally picked it up because I’m a tennis player and was very interested to read a book about tennis, and Taylor Jenkins Reid did not disappoint. Carrie Soto is not by any means a character I felt compelled to root for, but as she continued to develop and her story evolved, I found myself inexplicably drawn to her passion of the sport. I specifically enjoyed how Reid developed her character through the coaching of her father, Javier. Despite the bumps and complications of their relationship, Reid describes a genuine and emotional connection between the father and daughter, and it was beautiful to read.

Reviewer's Name: Cara
The House in the Cerulean Sea Book Jacket
Klune, TJ
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The House in the Cerulean Sea is a cozy, heart-warming story about a caseworker who investigates a top secret orphanage filled with magical children. This is not an intense read by any means, and it has a good bit of humor as well as some lovely commentary about the nature of love and chosen family. I thought it had a relatively slow start, but I'm very glad I stuck with it. I think this book is meant to open the hearts and minds of the reader alongside the protagonist. A refreshing, wholesome story that kept me hooked until the very end.

Reviewer's Name: Addison
Little Women Book Jacket
Alcott, Louisa May
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I really enjoyed Little Women more than I thought I would. The March sisters each have such distinct personalities, and watching them grow up and navigate life felt really relatable, even though the story is from the 1800s. I especially loved Jo, her independence and passion for writing really resonated with me. Some parts felt a little slow, especially the family’s daily routines, but the overall story is heartwarming and full of lessons about family, love, and perseverance. Definitely a classic worth reading.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
Jane Eyre Book Jacket
Bronte, Charlotte
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

I found Jane Eyre surprisingly emotional and engaging. Jane is such a determined and independent character, especially considering the time period the book was written in. I really appreciated how the story shows her personal growth and moral strength. The gothic elements added some suspense, especially in the Thornfield parts. Some sections were a bit long, but the story and characters made it worth it. It ended up being one of my favorite classics.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
Wuthering Heights Book Jacket
Bronte, Emily
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

This book was interesting, but also a bit frustrating for me. The writing and atmosphere are really powerful, and the setting feels dark and intense. However, a lot of the characters are difficult to like, especially Heathcliff and Catherine, which made it harder for me to connect with the story. I still appreciated the emotional intensity and the way the novel explores obsession and revenge. Even though it wasn’t my favorite, I’m glad I read it because it’s definitely unique among classic novels.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
The Great Gatsby book jacket
Fitzgerald, F. Scott
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This book felt really atmospheric to me. Fitzgerald’s writing style is beautiful, and the way he describes the setting and the characters made everything feel vivid. Gatsby himself is such a mysterious and tragic character, which made the story more compelling. I also liked how the book explores themes like the American Dream and how people chase illusions. Sometimes the symbolism felt a bit heavy. But overall, it was a really interesting and thoughtful read.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
Pride and Prejudice book jacket
Austen, Jane
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

I loved this book more than I expected to. At first, the language felt a little too formal, but after a few chapters I got used to it and started enjoying Austen’s humor. Elizabeth Bennet is such a strong and witty character, and watching her relationship with Darcy develop was really satisfying. The social commentary about class and marriage still feels surprisingly relevant today. Some parts move slowly, but the dialogue and character interactions kept me interested. Overall, it’s one of those classics that actually lives up to the hype.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
Good Girl, Bad Blood book jacket
Jackson, Holly
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Pip has become a local legend and internet crime solving star. Her fame grows exponentially after she publishes her podcast on Andie Bell's murder case, but she promises her family she won't seek out more cases because of the danger it put her and those she loved in. However, when her best friend Conner begs her to help find his missing brother, Pip decides to open one last case and find Jamie Reynolds.

I enjoyed this sequel to A Good Girl's Guide to Murder. In my opinion, the first was better, but the second was still very good. I finished it in less than two days. The second half of the book is especially interesting. Good Girl, Bad Blood doesn't just focus on the mystery, but also the relationships she has with her family, Ravi, Cara, Conner, and her other close friends. Holly Jackson does a wonderful job of exploring how the detective work Pip engages in affects her mental health and relationships. Personally, I found the emotional exploration more interesting than the mystery at times. Jackson makes sure to provide realistic emotions that Pip feels after being targeted while trying to solve her previous case. This book is well worth your time, especially if you enjoyed the first book in the series. It is an epic continuation of a story that started long before Pippa picked up the Andie Bell case.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
Bye Forever, I Guess
Meadows, Jodi
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Bye Forever, I Guess by Jodi Meadows is about Ingrid, labeled as “The Girl with Dead Parents” at school and treated like her popular friend Rachel’s charity case. While she feels invisible and pitied in real life, she secretly lives a completely different life online as a confident and well-known gamer.

After a falling out with her best friend leaves her isolated and ostracized at school, Ingrid unexpectedly connects with a boy through a wrong-text message. The two begin talking anonymously, and for the first time, Ingrid feels seen for who she truly is. However, things become complicated when she starts to suspect that the boy she’s confiding in might actually be a popular classmate from school, forcing her to confront her fears about identity, vulnerability, and trust.

In my opinion, this was a cute middle-grade romance with a sweet message about friendship and self-acceptance, though some parts of the plot felt predictable. I would recommend this to those who enjoy wholesome middle-grade romance, mistaken-identity tropes, and stories about friendship and finding confidence.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
Never Thought I'd End Up Here
Liang, Ann
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

After quitting her modelling career and accidently wishing her cousin ill health and a depressing marriage, Leah Zhang's parents send her on a two-week travel program in China. Leah is excited to reconnect with her family's culture, brushing up on her Mandarin and - hopefully! - impressing her aunt at the end of the trip. However, Leah soon finds that her childhood nemesis, Cyrus Sui, is on the trip, too. Deciding to exact the ultimate revenge, Leah hatches a plan to pretend to forgive Cyrus, only to break his heart in front of all their classmates when he eventually falls for her. But Leah soon finds herself falling in love with the boy she used to hate, and must grapple with her newfound feelings for him...

I was surprised at how much I enjoyed "Never Thought I'd End Up Here"! I was actually not looking forward to reading this book, as I don't typically read YA romance novels. However, I really liked the cultural reconnection plot, and Leah and Cyrus's trope was sweet and well-done. My favorite part of this story was the way Liang was able to convey Leah's mental health struggles, as I was really able to connect with her thoughts and insecurities. My only complaint would be Leah's revenge plot. Her idea of "seducing Cyrus and then breaking his heart" was not only out of character, but also juvenile and unnecessary. It made me dislike Leah's character, which was a shame. I think Liang could still have pulled off Leah and Cyrus's trope without the revenge plot. Overall, though, I would recommend "Never Thought I'd End Up Here" to anyone who is a fan of YA romance novels!

Reviewer's Name: Addelyn
Dial A for Aunties
Sutanto, Jesse Q.
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

When Meddelin Chan accidentally kills her blind date, the last thing she needs is to add a 2,000 guest Chinese-Indonesian wedding to the mix. Luckily, her immigrant mother and three meddling aunties are prepared to do whatever it takes to hide the body and successfully cater the wedding. With the aunties dealing with a wedding, a body, and Meddy’s unexpected college sweetheart, nothing could possibly go wrong, right?

I thought this book was really cute! I wasn’t exactly sure what premise I was expecting due to the many different conflicts, but I thought the aunties were hilarious and the plot was executed well. This book was very fast paced and not at all hard to read, and I especially liked the author’s note of how this book was a love letter to her culture and her family. I feel like it made the cultural elements of the novel much more compelling. Overall, the book was very simple and shockingly kept me in suspense the whole time just because I had no idea which way the story was going to go. “Dial A for Aunties” was definitely a fun and easy read.

Reviewer's Name: Cara
American Royals book jacket
McGee, Katharine
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

American Royals by Katharine McGee is a story centered on the House of Washington royalty, the monarchs that sit on America’s throne, generations after George Washington was offered the crown.
Beatrice is the heir to the throne, and will become the first Queen of America. Her parents insist on an arranged marriage, but her heart belongs to someone else.
Samantha, better known as Sam, is the spare. She’s always lived in her sister’s shadow and has had her share of flings, but the one person she truly wants is the only one she can’t have.
Jefferson, Sam’s twin, is America’s favorite prince. Charming and charismatic, he seems to have it all—except he has no idea that two very different girls are both in love with him.
In my opinion, this book was amazing! Katherine McGee’s writing style was engaging and easy to read, and the concept of an American monarchy felt fresh, unique, and completely intriguing. The shifting perspectives between characters kept the story dynamic and dramatic, making it hard to put down. I will definitely be reading the next books in the series.
I would recommend this book to those who enjoy royal drama, love triangles, and glamorous contemporary romance with a twist of political intrigue.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
We'll Always Have Summer book jacket
Han, Jenny
2 stars = Meh
Review:

We’ll Always Have Summer by Jenny Han is the third book in The Summer I Turned Pretty series and cannot be read as a standalone.
The story is about Belly Conklin planning her wedding with Jeremiah Fisher while also trying to sort her lingering feelings for her first crush, Conrad Fisher. This tension between the two brothers drives much of the drama and emotion throughout the novel.
In my opinion, this book was fine but nothing special. At times, Belly’s character felt frustrating, especially as she seemed to lead both brothers on and struggled with indecision, which made it hard to fully sympathize with her. The romantic tension can be engaging, but it occasionally borders on repetitive or overly dramatic.
I would recommend this book to mainly those who have read the first two books and enjoy summer romances, love triangle drama, and stories about coming-of-age and self-discovery.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
Hazelthorn book jacket
Drews, C. G.
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Ever since he was taken in by the enigmatic, reclusive billionaire Byron Lennox-Hall, Evander has never known anything except the walls of his room in his guardian's large gothic mansion known as the Hazelthorn Estate. Physically sick, traumatized, and orphaned, he remembers next to nothing about his childhood - except that Byron's grandson, Laurie, once tried to kill him by burying him alive. For Evander's safety, Byron has given him a strict set of rules he must abide by, including that he must never leave his room or go anywhere near Laurie alone. And he cannot, for reasons unbeknownst to him, go into the ever-growing, ominous gardens of Hazelthorn.

Then one day Byron dies a gruesome death right in front of Evander. And a look in Byron's will reveals something strange: all of Hazelthorn Estates and his riches will be inherited by Evander, leaving nothing to the rest of his family, including Laurie. Horrified by the sudden turn of events, Evander is certain that his caretaker must have been murdered, leaving him to find the killer. But other threats appear as Byron's eerie relatives begin to move into the estate, clearly wanting a claim on Evander's newfound riches, and as Hazelthorn's strange garden, previously off-limits to Evander, continuously grows, threatening to swallow up the Estate - and Evander himself. As unsettling family secrets begin to reveal themselves one by one, Evander is forced to figure out the ugly truth behind Hazelthorn Estates before the garden - or Byron's supposed murderer - gets to him, and he might just have to put his trust in Laurie, the boy who tried to kill him years ago, to survive.

I must start off by stating that Drews' writing style was very immersive in my opinion - I loved the dark, psychological style of the book, although at some points it felt a little overdone and edgy. The plot was, in simplest terms, insane: there were definitely twists that I never could have predicted, and each one was more surprising than the last. The body horror elements in the novel managed to spook me a little, which is rare for me. The book is fast paced, especially the second half, and each chapter left me with so many questions that I just had to keep reading for want of finding out. Evander and Laurie's relationship was also very complex - it was a genuine lovers-to-enemies story, and both of the characters slowly letting out their traumas and vulnerabilities gave the story emotional output and catharsis. I also enjoyed Evander's journey to self-acceptance, that feeling of finally breaking free from the confines one's been put in and learning to love oneself. Overall, it was personally a good read and a nice introduction to the body horror genre for me. I also look forward to potentially reading Drews' previously published work of a similar genre, Don't Let the Forest In.

Reviewer's Name: Joyce
The Summer I Turned Pretty book jacket
Han, Jenny
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The Summer I Turned Pretty by Jenny Han is about Isabel “Belly” Conklin who has spent every summer going to a beach house with her mother and her older brother Steven to visit her mom’s best friend Susannah Beck and two sons—Conrad and Jeremiah Fisher.
The story is a nostalgic summer romance centered on first crushes, family bonds, and growing up.
In my opinion, this book was entertaining and Jenny Han’s writing style was fun and easy to read. While the story was enjoyable, some parts felt slow-paced or a bit predictable.
I would recommend this book to anyone who likes summer romances, coming-of-age stories, and stories about family and friendship.

Reviewer's Name: Alaina
Awards:
Imagine Me book jacket
Mafi, Tahereh
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

Imagine Me provides a clear, satisfying ending for the second arc of Shatter Me books. However, I expected Imagine Me to be action packed and to make me not want to put the book down. Instead, everything felt slow and calculated, almost how you would expect the second book in a trilogy to go. Some scenes and plot arcs felt underdeveloped, or completely unnecessary.

While the plot was slow, and it was sometimes a struggle to pick up the book, Tahereh Mafi was still able to do what she does best: develop her characters. She established new relationships that built off previous experiences, developed all of her characters from the supreme leaders to the main characters we've been rooting for since day 1. I felt the characters are what made the book enjoyable, not the plot.

Despite Imagine Me's underdeveloped plot, I would still recommend it if you want to finish the series on a good note, with most if not all plot points resolved in a satisfying way. It just didn't have the same emotional punch in my opinion as the previous Shatter Me books, which is why I rated it 3 stars.

Reviewer's Name: Reagan
I Do?
Knight, Morticia
1 star = Yuck!
Review:

“I Do?” is a LGBTQIA+ romance featuring the main characters Chad and Raudel. Chad considers himself as a lowlife. He works at a yogurt shop and didn’t go to college. While staying at his sister’s house for her wedding, he realizes that she invited her friend from high school, his long-term crush. Chad tries to avoid Raudel, but it proves hard when they’re staying in the same room with only one bed for a full week.

I didn’t really enjoy this book. The pacing was too fast, the romance between the characters didn’t feel fleshed out, and it was overall too short. I definitely enjoyed the premise, I just think the book should’ve been longer, so the character relationships could’ve actually developed properly. If you like fast paced romances, then I would recommend it. However, I don’t recommend it to fans of slower developed romance.

Reviewer's Name: Madison
All the Better Part of Me
Ringle, Molly
2 stars = Meh
Review:

Sinter is in his mid-twenties, living in London for an acting job. He misses his friend since high school, Andy, who is in Seattle living his own life. While in London, Sinter starts to have different feelings towards his friend. He ends up moving back to Seattle to rekindle his friendship with Andy. But somehow, more than friendship rekindles, despite Sinter’s confusion on his sexuality.

This book is okay. The relationship felt somewhat forced, not enough for me to get invested. I didn’t really feel a form of connection to the main characters. My favorite character was one of the side characters, who I was hoping to get more lines almost throughout the whole book. It didn’t really feel like they had depth. The plotline is decent in the beginning, but then a wrench gets thrown into it. One of the classic but annoying tropes that I don’t like was used. It kind of made me want to drop the book, but I stuck to it. The book didn’t really improve much after that. It was decent enough; it just doesn’t really stick out to me.

Reviewer's Name: Madison