Book Reviews by Genre: Fantasy

A blue cover with a person falling
Sanderson, Brandon
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Even though it has been some time since I read The Final Empire , it is a testament to Brandon Sanderson that I could remember most of the details of this fantasy series when I got to the second book, The Well of Ascension. The magic system of burning different metals to provide a variety of super-powered abilities is such a unique idea that it easily sticks in my mind and is complex enough to explore further in this book.

While I love how Sanderson does his action sequences, I understand the need to lean more on political and religious intrigue in this second book to deepen the lore and world-building for the Mistborn series. Sanderson does a good job with these moments of loyalty and betrayal, and it shows the amount of thought he put into making this world realistic—at least in terms of how we understand our world’s politics and religions. However, unlike how Orson Scott Card did this in the Call of Earth series or Isaac Asimov did in the Foundation series, there don’t seem to be ties to real-world histories that weigh down what Sanderson is trying to do here.

Ultimately, Sanderson is a master of magic systems, and The Well of Ascension uses Vin to expand what allomancy can do. That Vin is the best character in the series so far is testament to how much she factors into the plot and the development of the magic system. The creative ways she uses her magic to move through the world is what makes the action sequences as entertaining as they are. I do hope I can get to the next book in the series sooner rather than later, just to see how things turn out for her.

Political intrigue mixed with great magical world-building, I give The Well of Ascension 4.5 stars out of 5.

Reviewer's Name: Benjamin W.
Genres:
The City of Brass book jacket
Chakraborty, S.A
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Set in eighteenth century Cairo, Nahri is a con artists who spends her days marking arrogant soldiers and planning her next meal. So when she accidentally summons the mythical djinn warrior, Dara, she sees her carefully planned life in turmoil. When he whisks her away to the magical city of Daevabad, Nahri discovers shocking secrets about her heritage and navigates complicated political affairs, as she also discovers that her companion may not be all he says he is.

The City of Brass is a high fantasy novel and made for a fun read! While I absolutely adore fantasy, the backdrop and the mythology in which this story is based made for a longer and more complicated read. The magic systems were intricate and the history of the djinn were incredibly complex. That being said, it’s clear that the author put her soul into writing this novel, as nearly everything was seamless! The characters were flawed and forced to navigate complicated political environments that challenged their personal morals, and the ending was crazy! I genuinely feel like all hope is lost now, I have no clue how the author can write two more books expanding the plot when so much happened just in the last 50 pages! If anyone is looking for a plot based high fantasy, definitely don’t sleep on this one, it was so much fun to read!

Reviewer's Name: Cara
The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy book jacket
Adams, Douglas
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy is an absurdist space adventure comedy about a man named Arthur Dent who is taken to space on a crazy adventure. I enjoyed this book because it had lots of weird humor and laughs. I think the author did a great job designing zany characters. The only flaw is that sometimes the ridiculous comedy makes the plot nonsensical. Otherwise, this is a hilarious and fun read that I recommend!
Reviewer grade: 8

Reviewer's Name: Dominic
A forest scene with the sunlight coming through the trees
Durst, Sarah Beth
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This is a cozy fantasy novel talking about a librarian who escapes a collapsing empire and opens a small spell shop on a quiet island. The story focuses on starting over, found family, and the comfort of simple magic rather than big battles. I chose this book because the idea of a magical shop and a calmer fantasy setting sounded relaxing and different. What I enjoyed most was the peaceful atmosphere and the relationships between the characters, which felt warm and genuine. Some parts moved slowly, but that fit the cozy tone of the story. Overall, this book was comforting, creative, and enjoyable, especially for readers who like fantasy without constant action.

Reviewer's Name: Xuejing
One Man Punch Volume 25 book jacket
ONE, Yusuke Murata
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This volume introduces more Dragon Level monsters such as Nyaan and their capabilities to rival Class S Heroes. The Hero Hunter Garou is shown to be growing in power reaching levels far beyond his capabilities before. This is shown in his battle against Class S Puri-Puri Prisoner. Saitama encounters Class S Hero Flashy Flash as he goes deeper in the Monster HQ. Skeptical about Saitama's presence, Flashy Flash strikes at him. He is left shocked at his ability to react to his light speed blitz. Flashy Flash remembers Saitama as Genos' sidekick labeling him as a hero.

This is one of the best reactions of the Hero Association's recognition towards Saitama's strength so far, it delivers a satisfying conclusion that more and more Class S Heroes are recognizing his potential. I love the buildup towards Garou's inevitable growth towards being a Dragon Level Monster, being able to adapt more and more efficiently towards any opponent, and looking more monstrous as he progresses. A great buildup story overall for the upcoming big events. The portrayed art style really brings the feel of a difference between power in the manga, whether it be on speed or strength which creates a heavy impact on the characters' own specialized abilities.

Reviewer's Name: Mark Tyler
One Man Punch Volume 24 book jacket
ONE, Yusuke Murata
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Continuing the story of the Hero association infiltrating the Monster HQ, the Class S heroes have been shown to demonstrate their value of power against the Dragon level monsters all while keeping a really good dialogue between the two sides. The art style, as always, is phenomenal especially on the fight scenes. The story so far has been so good now that we get introduced to more characters and lore behind the Monster King Orochi's origins.

Reviewer's Name: Mark Tyler
A Monsoon Rising
Guanzon, Thea
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

After marrying to form a political alliance between both their nations, Alaric and Talasyn are far from at peace with one another. However, as the two grow closer and the world hangs in the balance with the Moonless Dark upcoming, loyalties are tested and the two must question what their motives might mean for the other. Little do they both know something more sinister is brewing.

This was a great sequel to “The Hurricane Wars!” While I felt like a lot of the plot was relatively predictable, it still made for an easy and exciting read. However, at the very end of the novel, Guanzon wrote an astounding plot twist that I truly did not see coming! With heavy tension still laying between the two main characters and this new development of the story, I’m very excited to see what Guanzon will do for the finale!

Reviewer's Name: Cara
The Hurricane Wars book jacket
Guanzon, Thea
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

All Talasyn has known is the Hurricane Wars. Her whole life has been composed of fighting and defending her land of Sardovia from the tyrannous Night Empire. Following a devastating blow and a shocking discovery, Talasyn meets Alaric, the newly crowned Emperor of the Night Empire. Despite being sworn enemies, the two must work together to face a new and rising evil.

This book was really fun to read! I saw a lot of people saying it gave the same vibes as Rae and Ben Solo from Star Wars, and while I don’t really like that comparison, I love Star Wars and I could see a little similarity with the world Guanzon wrote. I do wish the novel was a little less romance focused, as I feel as though some elements of the romance plot overtook the main fantasy story. Overall, this was a very fun book, and I’m excited to continue with the series!

Reviewer's Name: Cara
City of Lies and Legends
Edwards, Kayla
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

In the third installment of the House of Devils series, Darien must race against the clock in order to save Loren. The cost? It requires him and his Devils to venture to a completely different city, Yveswich. Meanwhile, in Ker's bustling capital city, Roman Devlin only lives for one purpose: to protect his brothers. The last thing he expects is for Darkslaying rival, Shayla Cousens, to steal and blackmail him. Now, with both Darien and Roman's lives becoming uprooted, the true dangers of the conflicts in Terra begin to evolve in terrifying new ways.

Wow! Just when I thought the plot couldn't evolve any further, Kayla Edwards continuously proves me wrong! I'm so glad the author included the perspectives of both new characters and old side characters. It definitely helped shape the plot and furthered my understanding of the conflict. I also absolutely love the found family trope that begins to develop in this novel. While the story was steadily building towards it in the previous novels, the effects are displayed more clearly in this novel. As per all of her books, Edwards did not fail at making me feel every emotion. I laughed, I cried, and my heart broke on more than one occasion for nearly all of the characters. I am so excited to continue this series, and I am so upset the rest of the series is not written already.

Reviewer's Name: Cara
City of Smoke and Brimstone
Edwards, Kayla
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

In the fourth installment of the House of Devils, the city of Yveswich is in uproar. With the city rapidly declining and the imperator only allowing limited time to get out, the Devils and the other Darkslayers must race against the clock. Within Yveswich, a dangerous new magic is forming, and it is up to the Devils to save not only the world, but also one another.

This book made me feel everything. Looking back from the first book, the plot is so much more intricate now and every character serves a purpose. I'm so impressed with how the author is able to seamlessly implement relatively small details from the first novels and make them serve a much larger purpose in this book. There was so much foreshadowing in books 1 and 2 and I just did not notice it! As I have said with previous reviews, I adore the characters, and this book allowed for so much plot-focused character development. While the decisions of some characters made me angry, I could always understand why they would make the decisions they did along with the information provided to them. I'm so sad this is a continuing series and this is the last book that is published, but I'm so excited to see where Kayla Edwards takes this series next! It's very rare that nearly every book in a series is five stars, but the author writes this story so well that I can't help but find it perfect.

Reviewer's Name: Cara
City of Souls and Sinners
Edwards, Kayla
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

Following the events of “City of Gods and Monsters,” Loren and Darien have new challenges to face. With Loren being blackmailed and Darien fighting demons only he can see, the two are forced to engage in a continuously growing conflict that not only threatens Angelthene, but their world of Terra as they know it.

I love this series! This book had me in a chokehold with the amount of the emotions the author was emitting. These characters just can’t catch a break! I also love how she expanded the characters instead of just talking about Loren and Darien, it really helped give a new perspective to the plot and conflict. I can’t wait to continue!

Reviewer's Name: Cara
City of Gods and Monsters book jacket
Edwards, Kayla
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

In a world of werewolves, vampires, and other supernatural creatures, Loren Calla’s only goal is to survive as long as she can as a human surrounded by immortals. When her friend gets kidnapped in place of Loren, she has no choice but to accept the help of Darien Cassel, the head of most dangerous bounty hunting group in the city. Together, the two race to discover why a human like Loren is so valuable, and unearth the secrets of their city, Angelthene, while facing other indescribable creatures.

I loved this book so much! It reminds me of Monster High (which I was a huge fan of when I was younger) but for adults. I loved all of the character development and the conflicts had me on the edge of my seat the whole time. While some people may say the book was too long, I personally disagree. I feel as though the length allowed more scenes and development for the characters, which isn’t usually seen in novels as plot focused as this one. I will definitely be continuing the series, and I’m so excited to see where the author takes this story next!

Reviewer's Name: Cara
Earthlings book jacket
Murata, Sayaka
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Earthlings by Sayaka Murata is such an interesting and unique book, following a woman throughout her life facing trauma and coping with it in many unhealthy ways. She's unable to become a "cog in the machine" as she grows up, straying further and further from society. This book changed my perspective on many things, and I found some parts unsettlingly familiar. I went into the book without any knowledge of it, however as it is a sort of psychological horror and there were quite a few scenes with disturbing topics such as sexual assault, violence, and child abuse/neglect. Without spoiling too many things it's safe to say it's a very heavy read, but I found it to be extremely worth it, as it was thrilling, captivating, and I loved how the characters were written. (I'm in grade 12)

Reviewer's Name: Madison
Jurassic Park book jacket
Crichton, Michael
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Jurassic Park is a sci-fi thriller about a park that has figured out how to clone once-extinct dinosaurs and has invited two paleontologists to tour it. I chose to read this book because I love dinosaurs and have seen all the Jurassic movies. I enjoyed this book because it is an exciting thriller with lots of dinosaur action. I also appreciated how the author didn't hold back with the consequences of bringing back dinosaurs. Overall, this is a creative and masterful novel that I highly recommend.

Reviewer's Name: Dominic
Project Hail Mary Book Jacket
Weir, Andy
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Project Hail Mary is a sci-fi adventure book about a scientist and former schoolteacher, Ryland Grace, who has been tasked with a mission to explore another planetary system to discover the secrets of a sun-dimming microbe that threatens Earth. I enjoyed this book because it is filled with heart and comedy. I also appreciated how the author took time to explore the science of Grace's discoveries. It had a few flaws- sometimes the science distracted from the pacing, and some characters' choices didn't make sense. Overall, this is an amazing book that I enjoyed- I highly recommend it!

Reviewer's Name: Dominic, Grade 8
Lost Boy: The True Story of Captain Hook
Henry, Christina
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

For Jamie, life on the island is not an easy task. He's the right-hand man to Peter, the leader of their crew of Lost Boys, and no stranger to the dangers in their environment: ravenous beasts, pirates, sickness, death. Nevertheless, Jamie is committed to raising the boys Peter brings to the island to join their crew, as well as follow Peter's whims - after all, he is Peter's first and favorite Lost Boy. But when a string of tragedies happens and suspicious revelations about Peter come to light, Jamie grows disillusioned with his life and Peter's promises, suspecting that Peter's true character might be more sinister than he's ever imagined. This is the true story of Captain Hook.

I thoroughly enjoyed this darker twist on the original Peter Pan story. The novel was well-paced, the characters were developed nicely, and the more frightening moments of the book were able to leave me shocked and reeling, which doesn't happen too often. Jamie's story was devastating, and the book's brooding, visceral prose was able to encapsulate just how horrifying the truth about Peter was. There was maybe one plot development that I found a little unnecessary, but it did make sense within the story and had significance on the characters' emotional growth. I would also like to add as a small warning for prospective readers that I was a little surprised by the amount of graphic gore included - it wasn't over the top, but it was enough to be potentially triggering. This novel was an emotional rollercoaster - it did its job of ruining my former perception of Peter Pan as an innocent little elf, and it did it in a way I don't think I'll ever be able to forget.

Reviewer's Name: Joyce
Iron Flame book jacket
Yarros, Rebecca
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

This sequel somehow managed to be even more intense than the first book. The action scenes were amazing, and the dragons were still my favorite part of the series. This is a massive roman-tasy novel and really delivers high stakes, intense political building, and a dramatic climax. Violet’s growth throughout the story made her feel even stronger as a protagonist, and the emotional tension kept me invested the entire time. The ending completely shocked me and left me desperate for the next book.

Reviewer's Name: Caroline
The Memory Police book jacket
Ogawa, Yoko
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The Memory Police by Yoko Ogawa as a chilling yet heartwarming dystopia that dives into the intricacies of memory and identity. It follows the journey of the protagonist, an unnamed female novelist, as she navigates her changing world. The story is set on a remote island where objects and memories systematically disappear, leaving holes in the hearts and minds of the people. It leads the reader to question, alongside the protagonist, what role our pasts and our memories play in shaping our identities, and it masterfully taps into the fear of losing oneself. I have only rated this book three stars because although it was an enjoyable read, it got dull at times and I found some of the subplots to be more distracting than impactful.

Reviewer's Name: Addison
Carl's Doomsday Scenario book jacket
Dinniman, Matt
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

After mastering the first two floors in an 18 level Dungeon, things start to pick up as Carl and Donut reach the third floor. There, they can select classes and races. They can also complete quests. Though, as the title suggests, not all goes as plan. The Borant Company, controller of the Dungeon game show, keeps finding ways to make up new mobs, and the Dungeon AI is positively insane. Definitely an exciting read, and I personally am on the sixth book.

Reviewer's Name: Lucy, grade 8
Dungeon Crawler Carl book jacket
Dinniman, Matt
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

Right off the bat this book destroys the surface of Earth and turns the survivors into a deadly video game: Dungeon Crawlers: Earth Addition. This is not your average action book but instead an unpredictable battle for survival as Carl, and his cat Donut, enter the dungeon where they are forced to fight mobs, gain upgrades, and raise their level to survive. It's like a video game but all too real. If you are looking for a sweet book, maybe pass this one. I think it's a good book, but there is some language and adult jokes, so not for really young kids. Best of all, it is in a series, so once you put this one down, you can pick up another!

Reviewer's Name: Lucy
Weyward book jacket
Hart, Emilia
2 stars = Meh
Review:

“Weyward” tells the story of three women across generations. 1619: Altha is on trial in a town unforgiving of unusual women. 1942: During World War 2, Violet works to uncover the mysteries of her family lineage all while suffering tragedy on her own. 2019: On the run from her abusive ex, Kate navigates the hardships of starting over, all while discovering who she is in the process. All three women’s stories are woven together to form one story about women’s empowerment spanning generations.

I was very disappointed in this book. The premise sounded so interesting, and I was excited to read a story centering around female strength. Unfortunately, while the empowerment of women is a common theme, the story was so slow and actually made me feel bored. I was also shocked at how depressing some of the elements of the novel were. I wasn’t expecting a happy story, but so much of the book described tragedy and hardship that it was hard to feel rejoiced when the empowerment piece finally occurred. Also, this fiction novel includes elements of magical realism, which I felt did not serve a purpose to the point the author was trying to make. While I believe the women’s connection with nature was supposed to be a representation of their strength, the execution of the “magic” just made the story more confusing and did not add much importance compared to the other more significant aspects of the story.

Reviewer's Name: Cara
Gachiakuta, Vol. 2
Kei, Urana
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

The second volume of Gachiakuta is about Rudo joining an organization called the “Cleaners.” He asked to join them and agreed in order to help get revenge on the person who framed him for murder. However, it’s clear that something suspicious is happening on the ground, as the monsters known as Trash Beasts have been found with vital instruments inside them.

I think this volume is a big step up from the first, as lots of information is introduced. One thing that I really like about this volume is that the information dumping isn’t nearly as bad. Some things are still spoon-fed to the audience, but it isn’t as blatant as before. The introduction of new characters and world-building really brings a lot to the story, as things are becoming more interesting. I also really enjoy it when the audience gets certain information at the same time a character does. It makes the reveals feel more impactful and important. Another really great thing about this book is the art. It’s very unique and easy to follow, and it’s clear that the artist and author, Kei Urana, is very talented. I would definitely rate this volume higher than the first, but I still want to see where the story goes.

Reviewer's Name: Cierra
The House in the Cerulean Sea Book Jacket
Klune, TJ
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

The House in the Cerulean Sea is a cozy, heart-warming story about a caseworker who investigates a top secret orphanage filled with magical children. This is not an intense read by any means, and it has a good bit of humor as well as some lovely commentary about the nature of love and chosen family. I thought it had a relatively slow start, but I'm very glad I stuck with it. I think this book is meant to open the hearts and minds of the reader alongside the protagonist. A refreshing, wholesome story that kept me hooked until the very end.

Reviewer's Name: Addison
The Light of All That Falls book jacket
Islington, James
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This book is really entertaining, especially in the second half. In this book, the Augurs go to the Boundary to try to fix it but end of going through and getting stuck, Wirr handles politics and preparing the capital for evacuation, Caeden discovers what he must do to save the world and struggles with his immortal friends, and Asha discover what she must do to help the Boundary effort with her new wealth of power. I really enjoyed the unique struggles Caeden went through with the friends he is enemies with but has loved for centuries, it is a very intriguing dynamic. Davian’s captivity was always exciting to read as it explored his new relationships and struggles to exist in a world they can’t survive in and Asha’s new responsibilities show important themes about the cost of power. The first half of the book can be a bit slow as the setup continues and the entire series in general can be a bit confusing with the timeline, but I think the confusion isn’t too much of an issue and the ending more than makes up for any slog in the first half. It is a somewhat sad but satisfying end that tied up any loose ends very nicely and made me want to read it again as soon as I was done.

Reviewer's Name: Danielle
An Echo of Things to Come book jacket
Islington, James
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

This was a good book but some parts were a bit slow to get through. In this book, Davian and Ishelle train at Tol Shen and have to begin dealing with the issue of the failing Boundary, Caeden grapples with who he is and what his duties and past are because of that, and Wirr and Asha handle the major political fallout with the Augur Amnesty, the new Tenets, and having a Gifted as the Northwarden. This story has a lot of setup and world-building for the next book so it can sometimes feel a bit slow. However, Caeden’s journey was really satisfying, especially for people like me who enjoy the type of character that is basically immortal so have to deal more with issues of protecting their friends and the world and having complex relationships. It isn’t the best of the series but it is still good and important.

Reviewer's Name: Danielle
The Shadow of What Was Lost
Islington, James
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This book was very thought-provoking and interesting. It tells the story of Davian and Wirr, who run away from the boarding school for Gifted people they live at, and Davian’s journey in learning what his powers are and how to use them. It also explores Caeden, a boy on the run with strange abilities but no memory of who he is, trying to remember himself and help his friends; and Asha, maneuvering through politics in her new state as a Shadow with new friends helping her. I love the character development and writing style this book is full of, plus the plot twists I never saw coming but understood in hindsight were really nice. The characters’ journeys were very exciting, and I found myself reading this constantly, even on reread. I’m glad this whole series came out before I read it, so I didn’t have to wait for the next one.

Reviewer's Name: Danielle
Genres:
A Clash of Kings Book Jacket
Martin, George R. R.
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

This story was just as amazing as the first book of the series. There were so many interweaving stories as different sides fight to put a new king on the throne after the last one died with arguments over who the heir is and whether a section should secede. It’s very complex but has nuance that was interesting and didn’t confuse me despite its complexity. It’s a long book but it feels like it goes but in a flash with how captivating and entertaining it is. This is a book I wish I could read for the first time again.

Reviewer's Name: Danielle
A Feast for Crows Book Jacket
Martin, George R. R.
4 stars = Really Good
Review:

This book, while it wasn’t my favorite, was definitely good in a way that feels almost objective. The War of the Five Kings continues to rage on and Cersei, Jaime, and Tyrion create plans for power, bringing the other sides to submission, and to get what they want. Sansa wants to escape her captivity and takes on a new identity once free and Arya explores her new life in Braavos. My only issue with the book was personal preference for characters and stories I wish had been more prevalent, such as Arya, but the writing style is still incredible and the politics so common in this book are definitely appealing to a lot of people and to me a large portion of the time. This was a bit of a slower and harder one to read, but it was still quite interesting.

Reviewer's Name: Danielle
A Game of Thrones Book Jacket
Martin, George R. R.
5 stars = Bohemian Rhapsody Awesome!
Review:

This book absolutely changed everything about how I read. Any time I tried to pick up any other book before finishing this one, all I could feel was a distinct desire to be reading this instead. Ned Stark tries to navigate politics as the Hand of the King, Bran recovers from a traumatic injury and begins discovering capabilities he never knew he had, Jon works his way up the ladder as a recruit at the Wall, Arya tries to live in King’s Landing while still pursuing her passions, and Sansa is stuck between love, hurt, and loyalty between her betrothed and her family. The storylines were complex and nuanced but understandable and the writing style was so good it made many other books after it feel like children’s books in comparison. Truly an incredible read.

Reviewer's Name: Danielle
Station Eleven Book Jacket
Mandel, Emily St. John
3 stars = Pretty Good
Review:

What happens to the world if a deadly pandemic were to rush through the world? What happens when the world and civilization as we know it collapses? Station 11 attempts to answer that question by following the lives of many characters through the past and present. Arthur is a celebrity who can't seem to keep a marriage. Kirsten was only a child when the flu hit but now she is traveling in a traveling symphony sharing their love for the arts with the few towns that exist. The Prophet, obsessed with airplanes, wants to make the world normal again in... interesting ways.

The idea and the events behind Station 11 are amazing and the pandemic made me very interested in what this book could be. I find the characters to be interesting to learn about and see how they grow and change overtime. The themes of relationships, family, civilization, memory and reminiscing are powerful and make you think. Unfortunately I find that the plot of the book is nonexistent at times and can sometimes drag on. It also can feel very confusing at times as almost everything in the book is connected to every other thing making it hard to keep tract of the plentiful amount of characters and objects on top of the non linear format . Overall I would say that this novel is overall a good read with very captivating stories and themes but with some issues with plot.

Reviewer's Name: Samuel, Grade 11